Consistent Successfor Over 25 Years
Steven M. Sweat, Personal Injury Lawyers, APC
Justia Lawyer Rating for Steven M. Sweat
BBB Rating A+
Avvo Rating 10.0 Top Attorney
Top 100 Trial Lawyers
10 Best 2018 Attorney - Client satisfaction
Multi-million Dollar Advocates Forum
Super Lawyers - Steven M. Sweat - 10 Years
The State Bar of California
Client Champion Silver 2020
Lead Counsel
Top 10 - Personal Injury Lawyer

House Party Injury Claims California

January 8, 2015

House Party Injury Claims in CaliforniaHouse party injury claims in California, like anywhere else can and do happen when people decide to throw a social gathering in their home and don’t take adequate precautions to keep people from being hurt. Whether you live in an apartment or condominium in a large urban area like Los Angeles, San Diego or San Francisco or in a house in a more suburban area like the San Fernando Valley, San Gabriel Valley, San Joaquin Valley, Orange County or the Inland Empire there are times when homeowners and tenants want to “throw a big bash” for a special occasion like a holiday or birthday. Usually the serving of alcohol is involved, which can lead to some persons overindulging, getting drunk and causing problems such as assaults and battery or, even worse, driving under the influence and crashing a vehicle. This can lead to both party participants and other people outside the party being injured or killed. What do the laws of the State of California provide as far as seeking monetary compensation through the civil justice system in these scenarios?

The General Rule: “Social Host Immunity”

In general, California law prohibits being able to collect from a so-called “social host” (i.e. a private person not in the business of selling alcohol) who throws a party at their home or apartment. This is found in the California Civil Code and the statute reads as follows:

California Civil Code section 1714(c): “Except as provided in subdivision (d), no social host who furnishes alcoholic beverages to any person may be held legally accountable for damages suffered by that person, or for injury to the person or property of, or death of, any third person, resulting from the consumption of those beverages.” The Exception: Furnishing Alcoholic Beverages to Minors

The exception to this normal rule is when the host of the party knowingly serves alcohol to persons under the age of 21 years. A cause of action may lie for any personal injury or death that results from engaging in the provision of beer, wine or liquor to underage drinkers. Based upon California Civil Code section 1714(d), the law requires that the following elements be shown:

California Civil Jury Instruction 427: “Plaintiff (person claiming injury or the family of a wrongful death victim) claims defendant (person or persons being sued) is responsible for [his/ her] harm because defendant furnished alcoholic beverages to him/her, a minor, at defendant’s home.

To establish this claim, plaintiff must prove all of the following:

1. That defendant was an adult;

2. That defendant knowingly furnished alcoholic beverages to him/her at defendant’s home;

3. That defendant knew or should have known that he/she was less than 21 years old at the time;

4. That plaintiff was harmed by the minor; and

5. That defendant’s furnishing alcoholic beverages to the minor or minor(s) was a substantial factor in causing plaintiff’s harm.”

In fact, a recent California Supreme Court decision, Ennabe v. Manosa, (2014) 58 Cal.4th 697, this exception was further clarified (some might say expanded). The case involved an teenager who decided to throw a party at their home while their parents were away. A “cover fee” was charged to enter the party and alcohol was purchased with these funds. The majority of the partiers were under 21. One of the revelers left that party clearly intoxicated and, while driving under the influence, crashed his car into someone and killed them. The deceased relatives sued the homeowner (parents). The California Supreme Court held that the “social host immunity” rule did not apply because by charging a fee and purchasing alcohol, the host had become, in essence, a “seller” of booze who was serving obviously intoxicated minors.

The need for promptly seeking legal advice from an attorney following an injury or death resulting from underage drinking at a house party in California:

Given the general rule of immunity for social hosts and the exception of having to show either that adults were knowingly serving underage drinkers who were obviously intoxicated or that the “social host” was really a “seller” of alcohol by charging entry fees and buying liquor with the money, it is very important to seek out the advice of counsel in these cases. Prompt investigation is necessary to confirm facts and preserve evidence. When these claims are filed, the homeowners insurance company will step in to defend the claim and will, almost certainly, claim that “social host immunity” applies. Having a zealous legal advocate who can provide evidence of liability is crucial to recovery of damages for injury or death in these cases. Steven M. Sweat, Personal Injury Lawyers, APC is experienced in handling these types of claims and provides a free consultation regarding any same or similar claim. Our toll free number statewide in California is 866-966-5240 or our Los Angeles number is 310-592-0445.

Related Posts:

Civil Liability of Bars and Restaurants in California for Serving Alcohol to Minors

Client Reviews
I have known Steven for some time now and when his services were required he jumped in and took control of my cases. I had two and they were handled with the utmost professionalism and courtesy. He went the extra mile regardless of the bumps in the road. I can not see me using any other attorney and I would recommend him to any of my family and friends. Josie A.
Steven was vital during our most trying time. He was referred by a friend after an accident that involved a family member. While he was critical and lying in the hospital, Steven was kind, patient and knowledgeable about what we were going through. Following our loss, Steven became a tough and aggressive negotiator and made sure that we receive a huge compensation. I would refer Steven in fact, this happened 2 years ago and I still speak highly of his service. Cheryl S.
Mr. Sweat is a pitbull in the courtroom as well as settlement negotiations - You can't have a better equipped attorney in your corner! It is a pleasure working as colleagues together on numerous cases. He can get the job done. Jonathan K.
Because of Steven Sweat, my medical support was taken care of. Plus, I had more money to spare for my other bills. Steven is not only an excellent personal injury lawyer, providing the best legal advice, but also a professional lawyer who goes beyond his call of duty just to help his clients! He stood up for me and helped me get through the process. I would definitely recommend. I couldn't think of any better lawyer than him. MiraJane C.
I must tell anyone, if you need a great attorney, Steve sweat is the guy! I had an awful car accident and had no idea where to turn. He had so much to deal with because my accident was a 4 car pile up. Not to mention all the other cars were behind me and they were not wanting to settle in any way! He never stopped working for me and had my best interest at heart! Audra W.
I believe I made the best choice with Steven M Sweat, Personal Injury. I was very reluctant to go forward with my personal injury claim. I had a valid claim and I needed a professional attorney to handle it. I felt so much better when I let Steven take my case. His team did everything right and I am very satisfied. Stia P.
I have to say that Steve has been exemplary! I met Steve at a point with my case that I was ready to give up. He took the time and dealt with all of my concerns. Most importantly, he was present and listened to what I was going through. He was able to turn things around, put me and my case on the right track! The results were better that expected! Highly recommend!! Cody A.